The Real Fairytale of a Black Woman…?

Submitted by Amisha Upadhyaya

A Black Family Unit: the Real Fairytale?

A Newsweek article, “A Frog of a Different Color,” about “The Princess & the Frog” was surprising to me. Alison Samuels is a well-known black journalist, one of the leading voices of black women in America. In the article, she suggests that what is more of a fairytale than Disney’s movie is black women’s dream of a black family unit. Black men, she says, just aren’t sharing or wanting the same dream.

If anything, Samuels suggests, black women should let go of their dying fairytale and see what this modern movie has to teach, namely that it’s time for black women to look for men outside of their culture’s boundaries as the princess does.


The prince in the movie is not black. In fact, as Disney did with Aladdin, he’s an amalgamation of brown people lumped together: Naveen, the name of the prince, is an Indian name, with a French accent in Louisiana so….maybe he’s an Asian-Creole hybrid? (I have a friend from Montreal of Anglo-Indian Creole background so they exist…)

It’s radical to call it a day with one’s own men no matter how dismal the statistics Ms. Samuels cites or alludes to:  1 in 9 black men in prison, more than are in college; 35% of black male college grads vs 47% of their female counterparts; 14% of black men marrying outside of their race vs 4% of black women; etc. But are people stats?

Perhaps it is not giving up on one’s own but expanding one’s self.  Perhaps the frustration is high within the black woman’s circle.  Perhaps, as I see with other Brownie women, what Ms. Samuel’s is implying is that women — no matter what their color — ought to go for love rather than sacrifice it at the expense of an ideal or vision of how one’s life should be rather than reality. As the princess did.

Or perhaps these stats do not reflect the men giving up on themselves as much as society having given up on them or some combination of the two.

Am wondering how many within her community share Ms. Samuel’s viewpoint?



  1. Regina

    Yes, the stats are disturbing. But, the ground truth plays out one relationship at a time. Our personal perspective on life, perception of others in and out of our race are built as we interact with one another each day. If all your interactions with black men are negative, you’ll be quicker to return that glance of the non-black guy who shows interest.

    Regardless of the bad impressions others may have left us with, we ought to go for love versus chasing ideals. What are ideals anyway? Nothing more than baggage and myths of others that we adopt as our own? If we live long enough, we accumulate enough baggage of our own.

  2. Manisha

    Very well written…yes “we” (the society we live in) have a stereotypical, cookie-cutter sense of beauty. I believe that this is beyond just beauty and features but a norm that we try to follow, to fit, a function within the “acceptable” box. It is human nature for us to form common “interests” and fit in such as religion, communities, etc. We are less individuals than we think we are. We strive for individuality while we look for others like us.

    I would really hope, for the evolution of the race as whole, that art/beauty stops being categorized and ranked. These aspects are what provide us with creativity and a bigger step towards a better life.

    Note: I keep using the word “we” rather than “them” mainly as we are all in the same boat. If the boat is going to be ugly, we all are going to have to live in the mess.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s